Saturday, May 20, 2023

The Spoof is on Fire and Other Conflagrations

Gather 'round for another story time twofer!  Up for discussion are two very different stories about female survival, Elinor Lipman's Ms. Demeanor and Colleen Hoover's It Starts With Us.  

I'd never read Lipman but got sucked in on a recent Target run.  Ms. Demeanor is a romcom, and as such, typical territory for me.  But it's much wrier and drier than my usual fare, which I found kind of interesting.  Its heroine, Jane Morgan, is a no-nonsense litigator who never met a problem she couldn't debate her way out of.  That is, until she's caught doing the dirty on her apartment roof with Noah, an entry-level lawyer from her firm.  Noah gets a slap on the wrist, but Jane gets slapped with an ankle bracelet.  Forced to make the most of being confined to her building, she decides to get to know her neighbors, which she was too busy to do when banking billable hours.  One of them, Perry, turns out to be sporting ankle bling too (he stole a teapot lid from the auction house where he worked, but he had a really good reason!), and they quickly bond.  A lot of other stuff happens, but I found it less, ahem, engaging than the paradoxically unlikely-yet-written-in-the-stars relationship between just-answer-the-question-Jane and Perry-the-petty-thief.  What can I say?  I love love.

By contrast, Hoover's It Starts With Us is a lot heavier.  As you know, I read its predecessor, It Ends With Us, for book club.  Fans were so attached to that novel that they campaigned for Hoover to write a sequel, and although she never planned to do so (It Ends With Us having wrapped up exactly as it should have), It Starts With Us appeared on bookshelves -- and yes, in book club too.  You know how you watch a TV series and it ends and you're sad to see it go but you also don't want a reboot because that would undo all the hard-won resolutions of the finale?  Well, that's how I feel about It Ends With Us, and I can't even blame Hoover because it seems that she feels this way too.  That said, I did enjoy reading more about Atlas in It Starts With Us.  This real-deal knight-in-shining armor is the most compelling part of both books, a reminder that good guys -- and indeed hope -- exist.    

And that's the end of that.  If you get only one thing out of it, then let it be this:  

Look before you leap -- or *bleep* -- from a roof.

5 comments:

camdandusler said...

Thanks for your sharing:)

Ivy's Closet said...

Oh, sometimes..you wonder..if you take a little from this novel or that novel..would it be a better ending? Thanks so much for the reviews. I so appreciate them!
🧁🧁🧁🧁🧁🧁 I hope you have had a lovely weekend there..it has been such nice weather here. Although, I didn't take advantage of it as I should have. Instead, I made a Barbie couch. I have not been sleeping well this weekend. Hopefully, I will sleep better tonight.πŸ§πŸ’—πŸ§πŸ’—πŸ§πŸ’—I notice Colleen has been writing with other authors lately. But I haven't really been into her books as of late. Of course, I have my own characters that keep me busy..but I am trying to look into Susan Mallery.

ellie said...

Oh, I have to look into Elinor Lipman! Thanks for the wonderful book reviews. I feel as if I am in a lull as of late. I know I need to read more. πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—πŸ’—Recently, I was asking a co-worker if she'd watched A Million Little Things and she said no because the guy who stared in it was in Psyched and she loved that character so much she couldn't watch him in anything else. Of course, not having cable for so long I missed this show completely. It's always interesting to see what other people see in a show and what their favorites are. And now with the writer's strike.... better find some good books to read...or in my case..just write. Thanks so much for being here and thanks for all your inspiration! Oh..on one note I was watching the Japanese actor "Finn" in a new romantic drama..however, I like Finn more than the drama I was watching.

Caitlin'nMegan said...

Two book reviews! Oh, will you read any more of Hoover? I am glad you found such a fun one too! Of course, I might have too much Drama going on too. But then again, it moves things along, and yes, it's like a juggling act sometimes. I hope you are having a good weekend. All the best to your creativity and I relaxing too. Thanks so much for being here and thank you for your comments and much much moreπŸ’—πŸ§❤️πŸ’•πŸŒΈπŸ‹πŸ« 

Samantha said...

Another great twofer!!! The storyline of the first book sounds highly entertaining, and it's neat how fans wanted a prequel so badly for the 'It Ends With Us' book! It's refreshing to read stories where we can be reminded that "good guys - and indeed hope - exist". πŸ“š✨